Research Progress on the Mechanical Aspects of Stress Corrosion Cracking in Critical Nuclear Structural Materials and Welded Joints
AI · 2026-11-18
Abstract / 摘要
Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) is a critical degradation mechanism affecting the structural integrity and long-term reliability of nuclear power plant components. This review summarizes the research progress on the mechanical aspects of SCC in critical nuclear structural materials and welded joints, with particular emphasis on crack-tip stress and strain fields, stress intensity factors, local deformation, welding residual stresses, and mechanical heterogeneity. The development and application of fracture mechanics approaches, crack-tip strain-rate-based models, and numerical simulation methods are systematically reviewed. Particular attention is given to the effects of material property mismatch, residual stress redistribution, and time-dependent deformation on crack propagation behavior in dissimilar metal welded joints. Experimental investigations and finite element analyses reported in the literature are discussed to clarify the relationships between local mechanical conditions and environmentally assisted crack growth. Existing studies demonstrate that SCC propagation is governed by the combined effects of mechanical loading, local material properties, and corrosive environments. Finally, the limitations of current mechanical models and the challenges associated with predicting SCC behavior in heterogeneous welded structures are highlighted.
Methods and findings / 方法与发现
1. Research Progress on the Mechanical Aspects of Stress Corrosion Cracking in Critical Nuclear Structural Materials 1.1 Mechanical Factors Influencing Stress Corrosion Cracking Critical structural materials in nuclear power plants operate under high-temperature and high-pressure water environments while being subjected to internal pressure, thermal stresses, welding residual stresses, and operational loads. Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) is an important form of environmentally assisted degradation that threatens the structural integrity of nuclear components. Typical materials used in pressurized water reactor (PWR) primary systems include low-alloy steels such as SA508, austenitic stainless steels such as Types 304 and 316, nickel-based alloys such as Alloy 600 and Alloy 690, and their corresponding welding materials. Ehrnstén et al. [1] published a comprehensive review of SCC in austenitic stainless steels exposed to PWR primary water in the Journal of Nuclear Materials in 2024. Based on operating experience and experimental investigations, the authors identified cold work, welding residual strains, residual stresses, and externally applied loads as important factors affecting intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IGSCC). Residual deformation introduced during manufacturing, surface processing, and welding can significantly alter the local mechanical state of structural materials. In addition, stress fluctuations associated with thermal mixing, plant startup and shutdown, and operational transients may influence SCC susceptibility. These findings demonstrate that SCC susceptibility depends not only on material characteristics and corrosive environments but also on manufacturing history, local deformation, and the actual stress state during service. Consequently, mechanical factors must be considered when evaluating SCC initiation and propagation in nuclear structural components [1]. 1.2 Stress Intensity Factors and Crack Growth Driving Forces Linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) provides a fundamental theoretical framework for evaluating SCC crack propagation in nuclear structural materials. For a Mode I crack, the stress intensity factor, \(K_I\), characterizes the amplitude of the singular elastic stress field near the crack tip. The crack growth rate is commonly expressed as \(da/dt\), and experimental correlations are established between crack growth rate, stress intensity factor, temperature, and water chemistry. Andresen and Ford [2] investigated the mechanistic modeling and lifetime prediction of environmentally assisted cracking in iron- and nickel-based alloys exposed to aqueous environments. Their study addressed structural materials relevant to light water reactors, including Types 304 and 316L stainless steels, A533B/A508 low-alloy steels, and Inconel 600/182 alloys. By incorporating crack-tip mechanics, local environmental conditions, and corrosion processes into a quantitative predictive framework, the authors evaluated model predictions using laboratory and field data. Their work demonstrated that macroscopic loading parameters alone are insufficient to describe environmentally assisted crack growth. Instead, the local mechanical conditions at the crack tip must be considered together with the environmental reactions governing crack propagation [2]. More recently, Wang et al. [3] reviewed crack growth driving forces associated with SCC in nuclear safe-end dissimilar metal welded joints. Their review, published in Nuclear Engineering and Design in 2024, systematically discussed crack initiation, crack propagation prediction, and the effects of complex mechanical fields on crack growth behavior. The authors emphasized the importance of crack-tip mechanical conditions in heterogeneous welded structures. Their review illustrates the extension of SCC research from macroscopic crack growth correlations in homogeneous materials toward detailed analyses of local mechanical responses in complex welded joints [3]. 1.3 Crack-Tip Strain Rate and Environmentally Assisted Cracking Models Local crack-tip deformation plays an important role in connecting mechanical loading with environmentally assisted crack propagation. According to the slip-dissolution/film-rupture mechanism, localized plastic deformation may rupture the protective oxide film at the crack tip, exposing fresh metal surfaces to the corrosive environment. Subsequent metal dissolution and repassivation may produce repeated film rupture and repair processes that contribute to crack advancement. Andresen and Ford [2] developed a quantitative mechanistic framework incorporating the slip-dissolution/film-rupture process. Their approach linked crack-tip stress and strain fields, local electrochemical reactions, and crack growth rates. Compared with empirical approaches based primarily on macroscopic stress intensity factors, this mechanistic model emphasizes the combined effects of local deformation and environmental reactions on crack propagation. The study also addressed crack growth predictions under different material conditions and steady-state or transient environmental conditions. These contributions established an important basis for interpreting environmentally assisted cracking in nuclear structural alloys [2]. Nevertheless, crack-tip strain-rate-based models are applicable only when their underlying physical assumptions are satisfied. The relative contributions of oxide film rupture, localized oxidation, dissolution, and other degradation processes may vary among nuclear alloys and environmental conditions. Therefore, a single mechanistic model cannot necessarily describe all SCC mechanisms encountered in nuclear power systems. 2. Research Progress on the Mechanical Aspects of Stress Corrosion Cracking in Nuclear Welded Joints 2.1 Mechanical Heterogeneity in Welded Joints Nuclear dissimilar metal welded joints generally consist of low-alloy steel, nickel-based weld metal, austenitic stainless steel, and corresponding heat-affected zones (HAZs). Differences in chemical composition, welding thermal cycles, and microstructural evolution result in variations in yield strength, strain-hardening behavior, and local deformation characteristics among different regions of the joints. A study entitled “Stress and Strain State Analysis of Crack Front in Dissimilar Metal Welded Joints with Dual Field of Mechanical Heterogeneity and Residual Stress,” published in 2022 [4], investigated the combined effects of mechanical heterogeneity and residual stress on crack-front stress and strain distributions. The authors developed a numerical model of a dissimilar metal welded joint containing an axial crack initiated from the inner surface. Different crack positions and crack lengths were considered to investigate the local mechanical states along the crack front. The results demonstrated that the combined effects of mechanical heterogeneity and residual stress produce complex stress and strain distributions near the crack front, highlighting the importance of considering both factors when evaluating cracked nuclear welded structures [4]. Zhang et al. [5] subsequently investigated the effects of mechanical heterogeneity on creep deformation and SCC propagation in nuclear safe-end dissimilar metal welded joints. Their study, published in Materials in 2026, employed Vickers hardness measurements to characterize the mechanical property gradients within the welded regions and developed a finite element model incorporating continuously varying material properties. Under the specific modeling conditions, the predicted peak SCC growth rate for a crack located 1 mm from a material sub-interface was approximately 14.6% higher than that for a crack located 3 mm away. Furthermore, increasing the relative crack length, \(a/W\), from 0.45 to 0.60 resulted in an approximately 43.6% increase in the predicted crack growth rate. These results indicate that material property gradients, crack location, and crack length can influence local crack-tip mechanical fields and predicted SCC propagation behavior in heterogeneous welded joints [5]. 2.2 Effects of Welding Residual Stress on Crack Propagation Welding residual stress is an important mechanical factor influencing crack initiation and propagation in nuclear welded joints. Nonuniform temperature distributions, thermal contraction, and plastic deformation during welding can generate complex residual stress fields within the weld metal and heat-affected zones. These residual stresses may alter local stress distributions, plastic deformation, crack-tip driving forces, and crack propagation paths. Zhao et al. [6] investigated crack propagation behavior in reactor pressure vessel dissimilar metal welded joints under the influence of residual stress. Their study, published in Materials in 2023, employed the extended finite element method (XFEM) to analyze the effects of residual stress, initial crack length, and crack location on crack propagation. The numerical results indicated that, in the absence of residual stress, cracks tended to deflect toward the material with lower yield strength. However, relatively high residual stresses could promote crack deflection toward the material with higher yield strength. The authors also reported that longer initial cracks were more likely to propagate, while the influence of residual stress on crack trajectories depended on the material region containing the crack and its distance from the material interface [6]. This investigation demonstrated the combined effects of residual stress and mechanical property mismatch on crack propagation paths. However, the reported crack deflection behavior was obtained under specific numerical modeling conditions and should not be interpreted as a universal crack propagation law for all welded joints exposed to corrosive environments. 2.3 Local Mechanical States and SCC Susceptibility in Heat-Affected Zones The heat-affected zone of a welded joint experiences complex thermal cycles during welding, which may result in mechanical and microstructural characteristics different from those of the base metal. In particular, residual stress, plastic strain, and dislocation density may vary significantly across the HAZ. These local changes can influence oxidation behavior and susceptibility to environmentally assisted cracking. Xu et al. [7] investigated the influence of welding-induced mechanical conditions on oxidation and SCC behavior in an Alloy 600–Alloy 152M weldment exposed to simulated PWR primary water. Their work was published in the Journal of Nuclear Materials in 2024. The authors compared the local mechanical states, oxidation characteristics, and cracking behavior of different regions within the welded structure. Their results showed that the HAZ of Alloy 600 exhibited higher residual stress or strain levels and dislocation density than the base metal. The HAZ also exhibited a thicker oxide layer, deeper intergranular oxidation, and more pronounced cracking characteristics. Based on these observations, the authors suggested that stress-assisted oxidation contributed to the increased SCC susceptibility of the HAZ in the investigated welded system [7]. This experimental study established a relationship between welding-induced local mechanical conditions and oxidation-related cracking behavior. It also demonstrated that macroscopic loading parameters alone may not adequately explain the differences in environmentally assisted cracking susceptibility among different regions of welded joints. 2.4 Crack-Tip Creep Deformation and SCC Growth Rate Prediction In studies of local crack-tip deformation, some researchers have incorporated creep deformation into SCC growth prediction models to describe time-dependent deformation under sustained loading in high-temperature aqueous environments. Yang et al. [8] published a study entitled “A Quantitative Prediction Model of SCC Rate for Nuclear Structure Materials in High Temperature Water Based on Crack Tip Creep Strain Rate” in Nuclear Engineering and Design in 2014. The authors combined the Ford–Andresen model, a crack-tip creep model, and elastic-plastic finite element analysis to investigate the relationship between crack-tip creep strain rate and SCC growth rate. Compact tension (CT) specimens were employed to analyze crack-tip creep strain rates and their effects on predicted crack propagation behavior. Within the proposed modeling framework, the authors suggested that crack-tip creep strain rate could characterize mechanical factors affecting the degradation of protective oxide films. They further recommended the use of secondary creep strain rate for SCC growth prediction. The study also examined the effects of stress intensity factor, initial crack length, and creep duration on predicted SCC growth behavior [8]. More recently, Zhang et al. [5] extended crack-tip creep analysis to nuclear dissimilar metal welded joints with continuously varying mechanical properties. Their numerical results demonstrated that mechanical property mismatch near material interfaces could alter crack-tip constraint and local creep strain distributions, thereby influencing predicted SCC growth rates. The authors also acknowledged that their numerical model considered prescribed crack positions and lengths rather than autonomous evolution of crack trajectories [5]. These studies demonstrate that crack-tip creep strain rate has been investigated as a mechanical parameter for SCC growth prediction. Nevertheless, its applicability as a dominant controlling variable depends on the material system, temperature, loading conditions, and constitutive assumptions. The creep-dominated assumptions adopted in particular models should not be generalized to all nuclear structural materials without experimental validation. 2.5 Crack Propagation and Numerical Simulation Under Complex Loading Conditions With advances in computational fracture mechanics, finite element and extended finite element methods have increasingly been applied to investigate the effects of crack location, material interfaces, residual stress, and loading history on crack propagation in welded joints. Wang et al. [9] published a study entitled “Investigation of Crack Propagation and Mechanical Field Evolution at the Tip of a Growing Crack Under Variable Loading in Dissimilar Metal Welded Joints” in the International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping in 2025. The authors developed a crack propagation criterion based on crack-tip tensile stress and investigated crack growth behavior in dissimilar metal welded joints subjected to variable loading. Their results indicated that mechanical heterogeneity influenced crack path deflection. Crack propagation also caused redistribution of residual stress and plastic strain near the crack tip, while its influence on regions farther from the crack tip was comparatively limited [9]. In addition, Li et al. [10] investigated the prediction of full-life PWR primary-water SCC behavior in Alloy 690 welded joints. Their study was published in the Journal of Nuclear Materials in 2025. The authors proposed a dynamic crack morphology model and calibrated its parameters using available experimental data to predict PWSCC behavior under different conditions. This work illustrates the extension of numerical prediction methods from local crack growth rate calculations toward the simulation of crack evolution over extended periods. Nevertheless, the reliability and general applicability of such models depend on the underlying physical assumptions, parameter calibration, and experimental validation [10]. 3. Summary of Research Progress Research on the mechanical aspects of SCC in critical nuclear structural materials and welded joints has developed from macroscopic fracture mechanics approaches toward analyses of local crack-tip stress and strain fields, welding residual stresses, mechanical heterogeneity, and numerical crack propagation. The mechanistic framework developed by Andresen and Ford [2] established an important relationship between local crack-tip deformation and environmentally assisted cracking processes. Yang et al. [8] subsequently incorporated crack-tip creep strain rate into SCC growth prediction. Numerical investigations by Zhao et al. [6] and Wang et al. [9] demonstrated the effects of welding residual stress, mechanical property mismatch, and crack propagation on the evolution of local mechanical fields. Experimental investigations by Xu et al. [7] revealed relationships between welding-induced local mechanical conditions, oxidation behavior, and cracking susceptibility in nickel-based welded structures. Furthermore, Zhang et al. [5] incorporated continuous mechanical property gradients into finite element analysis to evaluate their effects on crack-tip creep deformation and predicted SCC growth behavior. Collectively, the published literature demonstrates that mechanical evaluation of SCC involves not only stress intensity factors but also local deformation, residual stress, material property variations, and loading conditions. However, differences in material systems, corrosive environments, crack geometries, loading conditions, and modeling assumptions must be considered when comparing the conclusions of different studies. In particular, numerical predictions and experimentally verified crack growth behavior should be distinguished to ensure accurate interpretation of the available research evidence. References [1] Ehrnstén, U., Andresen, P. L., & Que, Z. (2024). A review of stress corrosion cracking of austenitic stainless steels in PWR primary water. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 588, 154815. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnucmat.2023.154815 [2] Andresen, P. L., & Ford, F. P. (1988). Life prediction by mechanistic modeling and system monitoring of environmental cracking of iron and nickel alloys in aqueous systems. Materials Science and Engineering: A, 103, 167–184. https://doi.org/10.1016/0025-5416(88)90564-2 [3] Wang, Z., Xue, Y., Wang, R., et al. (2024). Review on crack growth driving force at the tip of stress corrosion cracking in the safe end dissimilar metal welded joint. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 429, 113609. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2024.113609 [4] Stress and strain state analysis of crack front in dissimilar metal welded joints with dual field of mechanical heterogeneity and residual stress. (2022). Article 2858320. https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/2858320 [5] Zhang, J., Cui, Y., & Chen, Y. (2026). Effect of mechanical heterogeneity on creep and stress corrosion cracking propagation in nuclear safe-end dissimilar metal welded joints. Materials, 19(17), 3722. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma19173722 [6] Zhao, L., Sun, Y., Shi, Z., & Yang, B. (2023). Analysis of crack propagation behaviors in RPV dissimilar metal welded joints affected by residual stress. Materials, 16(19), 6578. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma16196578 [7] Xu, X., Pan, D., Li, E., et al. (2024). Assessing the influence of welding-induced mechanics on oxidation and stress corrosion cracking in an Alloy 600–Alloy 152M weldment under simulated PWR primary water. Journal of Nuclear Materials, Article 155349. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnucmat.2024.155349 [8] Yang, F. Q., Xue, H., Zhao, L. Y., & Fang, X. R. (2014). A quantitative prediction model of SCC rate for nuclear structure materials in high temperature water based on crack tip creep strain rate. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 278, 686–692. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2014.08.012 [9] Wang, Z., Xue, H., Hui, Y., et al. (2025). Investigation of crack propagation and mechanical field evolution at the tip of a growing crack under variable loading in dissimilar metal welded joints. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 216, 105496. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpvp.2025.105496 [10] Li, H., Li, G., Sun, W., et al. (2025). Pr
Conclusions / 结论
Based on the published research on the mechanical aspects of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in critical nuclear structural materials and welded joints, the following conclusions can be drawn: (1) Crack-tip mechanical fields play a critical role in SCC propagation. Stress intensity factors, local stress and strain distributions, and crack-tip strain rates are important parameters for characterizing the mechanical driving forces of SCC. Fracture mechanics approaches and mechanistic models, particularly the Ford–Andresen model, provide theoretical foundations for understanding the relationship between local deformation and environmentally assisted crack growth. However, the applicability of these models depends on material properties, loading conditions, and corrosive environments. (2) Mechanical heterogeneity and welding residual stresses significantly influence crack-tip deformation and crack propagation behavior in welded joints. Variations in yield strength, strain-hardening characteristics, and residual stress distributions among the base metal, weld metal, and heat-affected zones can alter local stress and strain concentrations, crack-tip constraint, and crack propagation paths. Published numerical and experimental studies demonstrate that these effects depend strongly on crack location, material property mismatch, and loading conditions. (3) Numerical modeling has advanced the mechanical assessment of SCC, but accurate prediction remains challenging. Finite element methods, crack-tip strain-rate models, and time-dependent deformation analyses have improved the understanding of local mechanical behavior and SCC propagation in nuclear welded structures. Nevertheless, uncertainties associated with constitutive properties, residual stress redistribution, environmental interactions, and experimental validation continue to limit the general applicability and predictive accuracy of existing models.